Binaca Geet Mala 1954: greatest hits - Revision history

Pdewan: /* Notes about the credits */

2023-11-20T19:47:03Z

‎Notes about the credits

Pdewan: /* Two notes about the credits */

2023-11-20T19:39:10Z

‎Two notes about the credits

Pdewan: /* Raags in songs */

2023-06-22T17:50:38Z

‎Raags in songs

Pdewan: /* Two notes about the credits */

2023-06-22T17:49:01Z

‎Two notes about the credits

Pdewan: /* Two notes about the credits */

2023-06-22T17:45:11Z

‎Two notes about the credits

Pdewan at 17:33, 22 June 2023

2023-06-22T17:33:08Z

Pdewan at 17:31, 22 June 2023

2023-06-22T17:31:12Z

Pdewan at 17:27, 22 June 2023

2023-06-22T17:27:00Z

Pdewan at 18:12, 14 February 2023

2023-02-14T18:12:01Z

Pdewan at 18:09, 14 February 2023

2023-02-14T18:09:35Z

@@ Line 31: / Line 31: @@
 Surely not the maestro?
-Not likely. The full name of the Chopras’ favourite was Ravi Shankar Sharma, so it must be he.
+Not likely. The full name of the Chopras’ favourite was Ravi Shankar Sharma, so it must have been he.
 Indpaedia has been able to get hold of several black discs, of the type that used to be called SP (Standard Play, i.e. only one song on each side), which credit the ''been '' played in the film to ‘Ravi Shanker and Kalyanji.’ In both Hindi and Urdu, this instrumental track has been described as a gat (a composition). The Urdu credit tells us that the track is ‘bhaag 2’ (part 2).
 The word before ‘gat’ in Urdu could possibly be ''been ''. In Hindi, it reads more like ‘bom.’
 [[Category:Cinema-TV-Pop|B BINACA GEET MALA 1954: GREATEST HITSBINACA GEET MALA 1954: GREATEST HITSBINACA GEET MALA 1954: GREATEST HITSBINACA GEET MALA 1954: GREATEST HITSBINACA GEET MALA 1954: GREATEST HITSBINACA GEET MALA 1954: GREATEST HITSBINACA GEET

@@ Line 13: / Line 13: @@
 =The 39 most popular/ significant Hindi-Urdu songs of 1954=
-==Two notes about the credits==
+==Notes about the credits==
 [[File:  Taxi Driver Jayein To Jayein Kahan.jpg| Dev Anand and    Kalpana Kartik in the song Jayein To Jayein Kahan from the film ''' Taxi Driver  ''' |frame|500px]]
@@ Line 22: / Line 22: @@
 However, But Prof. Anil Bhargava, Mr. Harmandir Singh ‘Hamraaz’ and YouTube say that Ravi composed the music and Prem Dhawan wrote the lyrics. Indpaedia has followed them.
 [[Category:Cinema-TV-Pop|B BINACA GEET MALA 1954: GREATEST HITSBINACA GEET MALA 1954: GREATEST HITSBINACA GEET MALA 1954: GREATEST HITSBINACA GEET MALA 1954: GREATEST HITSBINACA GEET MALA 1954: GREATEST HITSBINACA GEET MALA 1954: GREATEST HITSBINACA GEET

@@ Line 1,786: / Line 1,786: @@
 =Raags in songs=
 Few film songs that have a root in Indian classical music remain faithful to a raag throughout their length. Indpaedia volunteers have sometimes mentioned raags even when there is merely a hint of that raag in a song. (‘Raag’ is frequently spelt ‘raga,’ while ‘taal’ is also spelt ‘tal.’)
@@ Line 2,811: / Line 2,814: @@
 <p class=MsoNormal><span style='font-size:14.0pt;line-height:115%;font-family:
 "Garamond","serif"'>&nbsp;</span></p>
 =See also=

@@ Line 20: / Line 20: @@
 ii) Who wrote the lyrics and music of the song ''Chandamama door ké pooé pakaaéiñ boor ke'' in the film ''' Vachan'''? Hindi Geet Mala credits	Ravi Shankar with the music and Ravi with the lyrics.
 However, But Prof. Anil Bhargava, Mr. Harmandir Singh ‘Hamraaz’ and YouTube say that Ravi composed the music and Prem Dhawan wrote the lyrics. Indpaedia has followed them.
 [[Category:Cinema-TV-Pop|B BINACA GEET MALA 1954: GREATEST HITSBINACA GEET MALA 1954: GREATEST HITSBINACA GEET MALA 1954: GREATEST HITSBINACA GEET MALA 1954: GREATEST HITSBINACA GEET MALA 1954: GREATEST HITSBINACA GEET MALA 1954: GREATEST HITSBINACA GEET

@@ Line 14: / Line 14: @@
 =The 39 most popular/ significant Hindi-Urdu songs of 1954=
 ==Two notes about the credits==
-[[File:  Vyjayanthimala in Man Dole Mera Tan Dole from Nagin (1954)a.jpg| Vyjayanthimala in Man Dole Mera Tan Dole from Nagin (1954)<br/> Colourised |frame|500px]]
 i) Who sang the song ''Chhota sa ghar hoga badloñ ki chhaoñ meiñ '' in the film '''Naukri '''? An otherwise reliable website writes: Kishore Kumar and Usha Mangeshkar. But Prof. Anil Bhargava, Mr. Harmandir Singh ‘Hamraaz’ and countless websites write that the female singer was Shaila Bellé and not Usha Mangeshkar. The film’s credits give the names of make up assistants but not of singers. SaReGaMa, that ultimate repository of Indian popular music, credits only Usha Mangeshkar (there is no mention of Kishore, though in the 60-second excerpt that you hear on SaReGaMa you hear only Kishore’s voice). This glaring  omission reduces the credibility of the SaReGaMa website. However, because of SaReGaMa’s stature, Indpaedia has gone along with it.
-ii) Who wrote the lyrics and music of the song ''Chandamama door ké pooé pakaaéiñ boor ke'' in the film ''' Vachan'''? Hindi Geet Mala credits	Ravi Shankar with the music and Ravi with the lyrics. However, But Prof. Anil Bhargava, Mr. Harmandir Singh ‘Hamraaz’ and YouTube say that Ravi composed the music and Prem Dhawan wrote the lyrics. Indpaedia has followed them.
+ii) Who wrote the lyrics and music of the song ''Chandamama door ké pooé pakaaéiñ boor ke'' in the film ''' Vachan'''? Hindi Geet Mala credits	Ravi Shankar with the music and Ravi with the lyrics.
 ==Binaca Geetmala’s Top 16 songs of 1954==

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
+[[File:  Nagin Sun Rasiya, Kaahey Ko Jalaye Jiya, Aa Ja.jpg| Vyjayanthimala  in the song  Sun Rasiya, Kaahey Ko Jalaye Jiya, Aa Ja from the film ''' Nagin. ''' <br/>Original colours. <br/>  The last 17m11sec of Nagin were in colour and consisted of one long sequence of songs. However, none of them made it to the BGM annual charts. Two other songs from the film did, including the no.2 song of the year. |frame|500px]]
-−
-[[File:  Nagin Sun Rasiya, Kaahey Ko Jalaye Jiya, Aa Ja.jpg| Vyjayanthimala  in the song  Sun Rasiya, Kaahey Ko Jalaye Jiya, Aa Ja from the film ''' Nagin. ''' <br/>Original colours. <br/>  The last 17m11sec of Nagin were in colour and consisted of one long sequence of songs. However, none of them made it to the BGM annual charts. Two other songs from the film did, including the no.1 song of the year. |frame|500px]]
 {| class="wikitable"
 |-
@@ Line 2,940: / Line 2,938: @@
 BINACA GEET MALA 1954: GREATEST HITS]]
 [[Category:Pages with broken file links|BINACA GEET MALA 1954: GREATEST HITSBINACA GEET MALA 1954: GREATEST HITSBINACA GEET MALA 1954: GREATEST HITSBINACA GEET MALA 1954: GREATEST HITS
 BINACA GEET MALA 1954: GREATEST HITS]]

@@ Line 2,910: / Line 2,910: @@
 [[Category:India|B BINACA GEET MALA 1954: GREATEST HITS
 BINACA GEET MALA 1954: GREATEST HITS]]
 [[Category:Pages with broken file links|BINACA GEET MALA 1954: GREATEST HITS]]