Floods in urban India
This is a collection of articles archived for the excellence of their content. |
Contents |
An overview
Asit K Biswas, Udisha Saklani and Cecilia Tortajada, August 31, 2017: The Times of India
Cities like Mumbai get inundated regularly due to administrative apathy, not climate change
While tropical storm Harvey in Texas has grabbed more international attention, flooding in South Asia has been quite severe: already a thousand people have died. This year, among the main sufferers of this regular annual event have been the residents of Mumbai, India's financial capital. On Tuesday , roads were jammed with residents wading through knee-deep water. Over 30 lakh commuters were affected by delayed local train services as train lines lay inundated. Overcrowded and flooded government hospitals are now facing the risk of spreading infections, exposing citizens to a public health crisis.
Residents were reminded of the 2005 flood that left the city in a similar state of paralysis. Over a thousand people lost their lives and essential infrastructure including airports, local trains, power and telecommunication systems were all shut down. Sadly , no real lessons have been learnt.
For most part of the monsoon season this year, a significant part of India has been submerged in flood waters.Incessant rains in Gujarat, Assam, Arunachal Pradesh, Bengal, Odisha and Bihar have triggered floods leading often to emergency situations. Most politicians, including Prime Minister Narendra Modi, have conveniently blamed climate change for floods that have impacted millions of people, paralysed local economies and caused deaths and serious economic upheavals.
India is one of the world's most floodprone countries with 113 million people exposed to floods. According to a UN report India's average annual economic loss due to disasters is estimated to be $9.8 billion, out of which more than $7 billion loss is due to floods. Flooding in urban areas is a particularly challenging problem. Similar to the havoc in Mumbai, several such events have occurred in some of the major cities such as Kolkata, Chennai, Delhi, Gurugram and Bengaluru during the past decade.
Climatic impacts on urban environments demand greater scrutiny and better planning. India has failed to offer any long-term solutions. Unplanned urban growth increases risk to natural hazards like floods. In addition real estatedriven developments, poor city planning, lack of accountability of all levels of government and political neglect have left cities to the vagaries of extreme climate.
Urban ecosystems comprising marshlands, wetlands, lakes and rivers which could attenuate floods have steadily deteriorated. Encroachment and illegal construction in flood-prone areas and indiscriminate destruction of green areas have steadily reduced the resilience of cities to withstand serious flooding.
Consider Bengaluru. Once a city of 2,500 lakes, it boasted an efficient storm water drainage system of interconnected lakes. If one lake overflowed water would automatically flow to another lake. With increasing encroachment and solid wastes blocking the channels, floodwater cannot flow to the next water body , resulting in frequent inundations.
Non-functional land use planning has impacted water bodies and drainage system in other major cities like Hyderabad, which has reported extinction of 375 lakes, and Delhi, where 274 of 611 water bodies have dried up due to neglect and exploita tion. Gurugram, a lowland area, has emerged as one of India's most important industrial hubs. Many of its residential areas are still not connected to any drainage system. Thus, it is not surprising that roads in Gurugram are severely waterlogged each monsoon season resulting in traffic snarls lasting up to 20 hours.
Proactive actions from municipal governments are essential to address the negative impacts of urban floods. Without strict adherence to land-use planning and construction laws, it is impossible for any city to manage its growing pressures and adequately plan its infrastructure.Not a single Indian city has a drainage system that can promptly evacuate intense monsoon rainfalls that occur over short time periods. Even these inadequate systems are never properly maintained.
In the case of Mumbai, the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) spent only close to 10% of its designated funds on civil infrastructure last year.Despite a budget of Rs 12,000 crore specifically allocated for development projects on roads, storm water drainage and water works, BMC did not take any initiatives to upgrade the infrastructure facilities. A report in this newspaper revealed that a large part of the BMC money amounting to Rs 61,000 crore lies in fixed deposits.
Even the funds that are used address immediate civic pressures rather than plan for long-term infrastructure creation. A similar situation exists in other major cities where the municipal corporations inflate their budgets but fail to carry out any significant developmental work.
Floods represent a major paradox.Nearly all Indian towns and cities are water-scarce in dry seasons and prone to severe flooding during monsoons. Cities like Delhi, which witness floods every monsoon, are also some of the most water-stressed in the world. This is a serious indictment of the poor state of India's water management.
Flood waters in urban areas should be stored for use during non-monsoon seasons, both in terms of groundwater and surface storage. This is essential if expanding Indian cities are to have yearround water security and control floods.These are controllable with proper planning including functional drainage systems, storing excess of floodwater for use in dry seasons and coordinated water and land use planning. Singapore, another monsoon country , has for the most part solved urban drainage and water security problems by installing a proper and functional drainage system and then collecting all rainwater for urban use.
It is high time Indian politicians stopped blaming urban flooding on climate change and started planning for secure urban futures. As Shakespeare said “The fault, dear Brutus, is not in our stars but in ourselves, that we are underlings.“
Asit K Biswas is visiting professor and Cecilia Tortajada is senior research fellow, National University of Singapore; Udisha Saklani is an independent policy researcher
Individual cities
Big cities are more likely to get extreme rain events
From The Times of India, September 2, 2017
See graphic, Big rain events’ in Indian cities, 1950-2000
Causes
Bengaluru gets flooded because it is 78% concrete: IISc
Rohith BR, Bengaluru floods because it is 78% concrete: IISc study, Aug 31, 2017: The Times of India
HIGHLIGHTS
Unchecked concretisation and acute loss of wetland and vegetation over the years are the two key reasons causing frequent flooding during a spell of heavy rain or monsoon in Bengaluru
High-density urban development in catchment areas leads to an increase in impervious areas in the city.
Thanks to unchecked concretization and acute loss of wetland, Bengaluru has been seeing floods during monsoon Thanks to unchecked concretization and acute loss of wetland, Bengaluru has been seeing floods during monsoon
BENGALURU: Unchecked concretisation and acute loss of wetland and vegetation over the years are the two key reasons causing frequent flooding during a spell of heavy rain or monsoon in Bengaluru, according to an IISc study.
Researchers from the Indian Institute of Science (IISc) said high-density urban development in catchment areas leads to an increase in impervious areas (where easy water flow is hindered, thus causing waterlogging or flooding) in the city.
The IISc study -Frequent Floods in Bangalore: Causes and Remedial Measures -says paved surfaces in the city have increased up to 78% due to years of unplanned urbanisation. Researchers have established the extent of concretisation by comparing the spatial maps of the city over the years and contrasting them with the ground situation.
The study says concretisation, narrowing of storm water drains, lack of appropriate drainage maintenance are resulting in urban floods -a phenomenon almost regular since the year 2000. If this trend continues, then 94% of Bengaluru will be concrete by 2020.
Prof TV Ramachandra from the Centre for Ecological Sciences, IISc, who led the study , said lack of planning and enforcement of laws has resulted in significant narrowing of waterways. He said floodplains (areas next to waterbodies) had been consumed by illegal developments, further leading to flooding in the city. "Encroachment of floodplains, obstruction of sewer pipes, manholes, dumped construction material and solid waste have blocked the system," he added. Bellandur Lake -which sees fire, smoke and froth every second month as an example of how not to preserve a waterbody -finds a detailed mention in an IISc study on the factors that cause flooding in the city.
The story around Bellandur Lake in east Bengaluru, cited in this study along with many others, drives home the point of concretization and narrowing of drains tellingly. At Jakkasandra village, which is upstream of Bellandur Lake, the main storm water drain has shrunk and 50% is concretized between 1908 and 2017, the study adds. Another highlight is 11.03sqkm Kaikondarahalli Lake, which joins downstream of Bellandur Lake. "This catchment is dominated by infrastructural (residential and commercial) establishments," the IISc report notes.
The study, conducted with assistance by researchers Vinay S and Bharath H Aithal of IISc, says there was no need to concretize the channel of storm water drains as vegetation in these drains bears the load in peak monsoon. "Drains with vegetation and without any bottlenecks would be the best option to mitigate floods. Narrowing channels and concretizing will increase the quantum of water and velocity, which would be disastrous," it added.
Hyderabad: failure to restore rainwater flow system
Syed Akbar, 'Orphaned' lakes to blame for Hyderabad floods, Oct 11, 2017: The Times of India
HIGHLIGHTS
An analysis of the satellite data reveals that it is the `orphaning' of scores of lakes that is causing floods year after year.
The flooding is due to failure to restore the original rainwater flow system developed by the Qutub Shahis and the Asaf Jahis.
The GHMC may blame plastic carry bags for flooding of posh areas in the city, but a detailed analysis of the satellite data reveals that it is the `orphaning' of scores of lakes that is causing floods year after year. The city has received only 22% excess rainfall since January 1. The flooding is due to failure to restore the original rainwater flow system developed by the Qutub Shahis and the Asaf Jahis. A little more than two-thirds of the lakes in and around Hyderabad have been `orphaned' with their inlet and outlet channels cut off due to unchecked urbanisation and encroachments in the last four decades. Satellite data and Google maps show clear-cut break in the network of water bodies.
Hundreds of lakes in Hyderabad were planned during the Qutub Shahi and Asaf Jahi periods in such a way that flood water from one water body flowed into another, ultimately emptying into the River Musi. All the major water bodies - Medchal lake, Shamirpet lake, Hussainsagar, Safilguda lake, Ibrahimpatnam lake, Dindigul lake, Saroornagar lake, Hashmatpet lake, Fox Sagar - were linked to the Musi.
But unchecked encroachments in the outflow and inflow channels has broken the vital water chain obstructing the flow of rainwater into the river.The major obstacles in the rain water drainage system built over 500 years, according to environment activist V Satyanarayana, are the Outer Ring Road, financial district in Gachibowli and massive unplanned constructions in Madhapur and parts of Cyberabad and neighbouring Rangareddy , Vikarabad and Medchal districts."The cutting down of hillocks and unplanned roads have created a paradox of sorts - the upper reaches of Musi remaining dry and the lower reaches, downstream of Hyderabad, receiving heavy flood discharge," he said. Despite heavy rainfall in the last one month, the inflow into the Musi river and its tributary Esi, besides Osmansagar and Himayatsagar lakes and other major water bodies has been minimal. The lakes that are overflowing is a consequent of encroachments in the lake bed. The city has received 218.2 mm of rainfall in the last 10 days as against normal of 39.9 mm, an excess of 447%.
A day after Ramanthapur received 8.58cm rainfall, colonies there continued to be inundated on Tuesday, leaving hundreds of families stranded in their homes.Speaking about the collective plight of locals, Bhagyalaxmi Gundapaneni, a resident of Rajendra Nagar Colony said: "Although it did not rain, we were forced to stay indoors as the water levels did not recede." Many of them were later rescued, in boats, by staffers of GHMC who took up relief works in rain-hit pockets.The GHMC also distributed food and water packets to hut dwellers living around the Ramanthapur Pedda Cheruvu. Apart from this colonies, around 200 households and 10 apartments in Ravindra Nagar Colony, Laxmi Nagar Colony and Sai Chitra Nagar Colony were also completely inundated. Urban planners attributed the adversity to years of encroachment and sewage dumping Woman rowed to safety, heads for surgery
Stuck in flood waters at Ramanthapur, a rescued woman could eventually fly to Chennai for a scheduled surgery on Tuesday Reaching her house to carry out the rescue was no easy task for officials. As the overflowing Ramanthapur Pedda Cheruvu inundated localities nearby, it became impossible for residents to come out. Following a request by her brother Mohan, officials carried out a rescue operation to bring her to safety Around 10am on Tuesday, a motorboat was sent to fetch the woman and her family. The motorboat could not be used as its base was touching the ground at some place. As a way out, workers decided to pull the motorboat and also rowed it across to dry land from the house of the woman at Laxminagar colony which was 400 metres away from a dry road Officials were not ferrying people but this was done as a case of emergency. "We have been informed that they went to the airport and took off for Chennai for her scheduled surgery," said C Uma Gowri, assistant medical officer of health, C2, Uppal, GHMC
Water stagnation and damaged roads continued to haunt residents of Nizampet, who rued how the situation is much the same every monsoon. The area was left flooded after water from the nearby Turka Cheruvu and Amber Cheruvu overflowed, following Monday's downpour. Most affected were those living in the Bandari layout and Reddy's Avenue, located on the edge of these lakes as the water gushed into their homes by late evening. Residents here said how despite multiple complaints registered with the gram panchayat, their grievances have not been addressed so far. "Encroachment on the Turka Cheruvu and Papayya Kunta canals has obstructed the water flow, thus leaving our area vulnerable to inundation. People residing in houses on Road No 2 D and 1 D were unable to move out of their homes due to water stagnation in the area. Residents are worried that they'll be left trapped inside their houses in case the city witnesses more rains," said Jagadeesh Babu Swarn, secretary, Reddy's Avenues Owners Association. Even last monsoon, area four-square-km area remained submerged for 20 days forcing the state government to make arrangements to evacuate residents to safety. With no relief this year, residents have decided to raise their concerns with the Ranga Reddy district collector
Following days of intermittent rainfall, residents of Alwal, on Tuesday, woke up to overflowing drains and stagnant water on the roads. The area had recorded a total rainfall of 4cm on Monday evening.Speaking about the harrowing experience, locals said how the several parts of Alwal -such as Temple Street and Bhudevi Nagar -have remained flooded for the last five days throwing normal life out of gear. "Water from adjacent Alwal Lake has flowed into the lanes causing immense inconvenience to residents. Since it a low-lying area, the water has no place to go and has, thus, remained stagnant," said Nikhil Jakka, resident of area. Hassled by the civic crisis, some people took to Twitter to reach out to minister for municipal administration and urban development K T Rama Rao."Sir, kindly look into this matter. We are suffering from waterlogging since two days in Bhudevi Nagar, Sai Dutta colony, Alwal," tweeted Syed Zuber
The 6.1 cm rainfall that lashed Madhapur, within a span of an hour on Monday evening, was enough to flood this IT belt of the city. Most of the complaints poured in from Kavuri Hills, Phase 1, where residents were left struggling to step out of their homes because of the waterlogged roads and overflowing drains. "With drains overflowing and severe waterlogging, the lane that connects us to the main road was inaccessible.Locals in our area had to identify alternate roads, which were also muddy, to travel to their destinations," said Sameer Kumar, a software engineer and resident of Sahiti Vidya's Siri Signature, a gated community in the area. Here too, residents squarely put the blame on civic authorities for failing to pay any heed to their repeated complaints regarding waterlogging."Water logging has been an issue that we have been battling since July. We filed a complaint with the GHMC on September 30, but the authorities are yet to find a solution to the problem. They have instead, conveniently, passed the buck on to the promoters of a nearby construction project claiming that it has blocked the drainage system that's in place in the area," said Kumar
